pidan Tofu Cat Litter Clumping,Flushable,Ultra Absorbent and Fast Drying, 100% Natural Ingredients Litter,Solubility in Water,Really Dust-Free,Less Scattering (5.3lb×2bags)

Very low dust, low tracking, low odor
I have tried a lot and I mean a LOT of non-clay cat litters. Pretty much anything that can be made into litter, I’ve tried it at least once. I have a favorite litter but the company went out of business years ago. Since its not likely to ever come back, this is now my top choice for litter. My previous top choice, Okocat, hit all the marks but the quality of it changed so the amount of dust and tracking became untenable. After a lot (a LOT) of searching, I came across this and decided to try it. I’m so glad I did!First off, though this is pellets, it’s not large pellets like other brands. That makes it acceptable to our cats who hate the larger pellets. It takes a little more effort to shake the unused litter through the scoop, but not that much more than other litters. I recommend a scoop with larger holes. And because it’s pellets that are larger than other litter particles, it cuts way down on tracking. I have to sweep around the litter box every other day and once in a while I’ll find a pellet tracked into the living room but it’s a far cry from my socks picking up sawdust all over the house or thick layers of pine or walnut dust covering everything near the litterboxes. The pellets can get crushed or break apart but any dust as a result is so minimal I have yet to notice after a year of using this litter. Our calico has allergies and this litter doesn’t aggravate her sinuses at all, unlike dustier litters we’ve tried.It clumps urine VERY well. There is some breaking apart that happens but no more than other litters I’ve tried. It doesn’t clump to feces as well but it does desiccate them enough that I don’t have a big mess when the Manx decides to eat something she’s not supposed to and then has…unfortunate bowel issues as a result.The litter is unscented so there’s not much of a smell. When it’s first opened, it has a smell that sometimes is like sweetened condensed milk, sometimes like vanilla, it’s always a bit different depending on the batch, I assume. It’s never unpleasant. It also keeps the cat box smell away to the point we never smell urine and only poo if the Manx has had a particularly smelly session. Once it’s covered, the smell dissipates quickly.That being said, there CAN be a smell akin to old cabbage. However, that’s only happened if the litter didn’t get scooped in a timely manner, I got lazy and the Litter Genie got overfull, or it was a past time to change the litter and clean the boxes. And that is the only thing I would caution when it comes to whether you choose this litter. If you can’t scoop every day, if you don’t have a Litter Genie or disposable bags you can take out every time you scoop, then this is not the litter for you because you will have that smell of old cabbage or fermenting cruciferous vegetables.We have three high-sided jumbo litter boxes, open top, not enclosed. Two boxes get one and a half bags of litter, the third gets two bags. I scoop each box every evening, takes less than five minutes. The waste goes into a Litter Genie that I usually remember to empty weekly. Once a month I empty out the litter and scrub the boxes, then replace with fresh litter. And we have no cat smell in the house. I am perpetually paranoid that there’s a smell thanks to previous experiences with other litters but so far there’s been no complaints. One of our neighbors even said “I don’t mean to offend you, but why does your house not smell like cats?” so I consider that a good indication that this litter and our setup is working.My one complaint is that the urine clump can stick a bit to the bottom of the box, but it comes up easily with a quick scrape and always comes off when I do the monthly box scrub. And really, I had that same issue with other litters, especially clay, so it’s barely an issue. I have not had any issues with the litter turning to sludge, though I can see how that could happen if the box wasn’t scooped regularly.

Amazing but just not financially sustainable
I love this litter, like really. The tracking is incredibly minimal, especially in comparison to clay litter, and I rarely ever smell the litterbox except with my kitten poos. It clumps well, making it easy to scoop, but it does sometimes stick to the scooper so it requires some cleaning every once in awhile. I haven’t really any dust, and while neither my cat nor I have allergies, it is still great to keep unnecessary dust away. The reason I’m giving it only 4 stars is really due to the price point, which is a common factor among other’s reviews. I’ve looked into possibly starting to mix this with another, cheaper tofu litter/corn litter to cut down on costs as it takes 2 bags of this to fill my large stainless steel litterbox. I also have to top off the litterbox every week/week and a half, so at the price point it’s just not the most sustainable or affordable option.

Very pleased

Overall the litter works well, clumps really well, easy to scoop (I don’t flush it so can’t comment on that), still some tracking but less than with clay, and no dust (which is as my primary concern)The reason for the low star count is the smell. It has a vanilla type smell and it is just too strong. I will use what I have because this is an expensive litter, but I will not be ordering again due to the smell.